Charlie Campbell vs Scott Smith – Mock Draft Accuracy

This page compares the mock draft accuracy of Charlie Campbell (WalterFootball) and Scott Smith (4for4) across 4 shared years of NFL mock drafts. Scores are computed using the Huddle Report scoring system: 1 point for each player drafted in Round 1, plus 2 bonus points for a correct player-team match, for a maximum of 96 points per year.

The aggregate view above shows combined multi-year totals, while year-by-year tabs break down every pick so you can see exactly where each analyst gained or lost points. Hover or tap any pick for details on scoring.

Year-by-Year Breakdowns

• Charlie Campbell vs Scott Smith — 2026 Mock Draft
• Charlie Campbell vs Scott Smith — 2025 Mock Draft
• Charlie Campbell vs Scott Smith — 2024 Mock Draft
• Charlie Campbell vs Scott Smith — 2023 Mock Draft

Analyst Profiles

• Charlie Campbell — WalterFootball • 6-year track record
• Scott Smith — 4for4 • 4-year track record

Related

• Mock Draft Accuracy Leaderboard — full analyst rankings
• Compare Mock Drafts — pick any two analysts or users
• First Round Misses — which predicted players fell out of Round 1
• Build Your 2026 Mock Draft — create your own and get scored