SS

Scott Smith

4for4
#5 Most Accurate Analyst
5-Year Avg (HR)
43.2/64
Best Year
48/64 (2025)
2026 Prediction
April 22–23 · Pre-Draft
View details →

Scott Smith is a veteran NFL Draft analyst for 4for4, one of the leading fantasy football and NFL Draft content sites. He is the #5 most accurate NFL mock draft analyst over the past five years (2021–2025), according to The Huddle Report's 5-Year King of the Hill rankings ↗. He averages 43.2 out of 64 points per year.

Smith publishes his final mock draft annually on 4for4, typically in the days leading up to the draft. His best season was 48 points in 2025, and his consistent accuracy across five years places him among the elite mock draft analysts tracked by the Huddle Report.

Year-by-Year Accuracy

Scoring: 1 pt for player placed in Round 1, 2 pts for player-team match. Maximum possible score is 64 per year (32 picks × 2 pts).

Why do these scores differ?
The Huddle Report ↗ scores are official numbers from thehuddlereport.com, where analysts submit their mocks directly. The “Calculated” scores are what we compute from each analyst’s publicly posted online mock draft. Analysts may submit a different mock to the Huddle Report than what they publish online, leading to score differences.
HR Official
38
of 64 pts
59%
View Profile →
HR Official
46
of 64 pts
72%
View Profile →
HR Official
41
Calc: 34
of 62 pts
66%
View Breakdown →
HR Official
43
Calc: 34
of 64 pts
67%
View Breakdown →
HR Official
48
Calc: 36
of 64 pts
75%
View Breakdown →
5-Year Average (HR)
43.2
Calc: 37.6
Best Year (HR)
48 (2025)
Calc Best: 46 (2022)
Best % Accuracy
75%

Sources & Links

🔗The Huddle Report – 5-Year King of the Hill🔗4for4 – Scott Smith🔗2025 Mock Draft – 4for4🔗2024 Mock Draft – 4for4🔗2023 Mock Draft – 4for4

See Also

LP
Lou Pickney
Mock Draft NFL · #4 Most Accurate Analyst
JB
Jason Boris
Times News · #1 Most Accurate Analyst · 8x King of the Hill
JS
Jared Smola
Draft Sharks · #3 Most Accurate Analyst

Think you can beat Scott Smith? Build your own mock draft and find out.

Build My 2026 Mock DraftView Full Leaderboard