🏆 Most Accurate NFL Mock Drafts – Past 5 Years

Compare your mock draft score against 203+ analysts using the Huddle Report scoring system — max 96 pts/yr. Don't have a score yet? Build your mock draft →

All Time Past 5 Years Past 3 Years

Showing 98 entries · 98 analysts · 0 users · 1 consensus mock≥75%≥60%≥45%

✓ all years Huddle Report official · ◐ partly official · * unofficial score (HR did not score that analyst-year). Official scores always take precedence where they exist. Learn more →

Rank	Name	HR	FP	2022	2023	2024	2025	2026	Total ▼	Avg/Yr
🥇	Jason Boris Times News 👑 2024 HR Champion · View Profile →	✓	✓	40	40	59	51	45	235	47.0
🥈	Charlie Campbell WalterFootball 📊 2021 FP Champion · View Profile →		✓	48*	41*	53*	46*	39*	227	45.4
🥉	Nick Guarisco Fantasy Law Guy ⚖️ MDDB Top-6 2019–21 · View Profile →			42*	43*	43*	48*	45*	221	44.2
4	Scott Smith 4for4 📊 View Profile →	✓	✓	46	41	43	48	40	218	43.6
5	Brendan Donahue Sharp Football Analysis 📊 View Profile →	✓	✓	40	42	44	46	44	216	43.2
6	Matthew Freedman Fantasy Life 📊 View Profile →	✓	✓	43	39	48	43	43	216	43.2
7	Jared Smola Draft Sharks 📊 View Profile →	✓	✓	46	32	48	49	40	215	43.0
8	Forrest N. Long The Huddle Report	✓		48	39	42	43	41	213	42.6
9	Ron Stewart YouTube	✓		48	38	45	48	34	213	42.6
10	Lance Zierlein NFL.com 📺 NFL.com Senior Analyst · View Profile →	◐	✓	42	39	44	38	50*	213	42.6
11	Walter Cherepinsky WalterFootball 📊 2x Top-5 FantasyPros · View Profile →		✓	41*	44*	42*	47*	39*	213	42.6
12	Benjamin Klotz Touchdown Squad	✓		42	37	45	44	44	212	42.4
13	Daniel Jeremiah NFL Network 📺 Former NFL Scout · View Profile →	✓	✓	40	43	42	42	45	212	42.4
14	Ryan Towles The Huddle Report	✓		42	38	49	43	40	212	42.4
15	Andrew Erickson FantasyPros	✓	✓	41	33	50	45	42	211	42.2
16	Kennedy Paynter Drafttek	✓		44	38	46	41	42	211	42.2
17	Ryan McCrystal Draft Ace	✓	✓	43	34	51	40	43	211	42.2
18	Brian Johannes The Huddle Report	✓		44	32	49	43	42	210	42.0
19	Peter Schrager NFL Network 📺 3x Top-10 FantasyPros · View Profile →	✓	✓	41	31	53	42	42	209	41.8
20	Ben Standig The Athletic	✓	✓	48	37	45	39	39	208	41.6
21	Mike Band Next Gen Stats / RosterWatch	✓		39	37	53	36	43	208	41.6
22	Michael Middlehurst-Schwartz USA Today	✓	✓	45	37	44	37	44	207	41.4
23	Mel Kiper Jr. ESPN 📺 Draft Expert Since 1984 · View Profile →	◐	✓	40*	34*	49*	47	36	206	41.2
24	Brian Phlipot The Football Hub	✓	✓	37	39	46	41	42	205	41.0
25	Eric Galko Optimum Scouting	✓		42	36	42	41	44	205	41.0
26	Lou Pickney Mock Draft NFL 📊 View Profile →	✓	✓	41	43	45	39	37	205	41.0
27	Walt Deptula The Roar FM	✓		39	42	43	40	41	205	41.0
28	Tom Downey Chat Sports	✓		45	37	46	39	37	204	40.8
29	John Daigle Establish The Run	✓	✓	39	44	43	41	36	203	40.6
30	Mark Niemi The Huddle Report	✓		38	34	43	46	42	203	40.6
31	Scott Atkins FullTime Fantasy	✓		38	40	37	42	46	203	40.6
32	Xavier Cromartie Fantasy Football Metrics	✓		41	35	47	39	41	203	40.6
33	Jeremy Bissett The Bissett Perspective	✓		40	39	43	41	39	202	40.4
34	Peter Clarke The Huddle Report	✓		41	36	45	43	36	201	40.2
35	Shawn Baptist The Huddle Report	✓		40	35	47	38	41	201	40.2
36	Kevin Hanson Eat Drink & Sleep Football	✓	✓	34	32	48	46	40	200	40.0
37	Matthew Jones FantasyPros	✓	✓	41	38	43	41	37	200	40.0
38	Jonathan Cook The Huddle Report	✓		44	35	48	41	31	199	39.8
39	Michael Delaney The Huddle Report	✓		43	38	42	40	36	199	39.8
40	Russell Brown FantasyPros / LionsWire 📊 View Profile →	✓	✓	38	40	48	36	37	199	39.8
41	Nick Jacobs KSHB-TV	✓		36	26	43	52	41	198	39.6
42	Ross Jacobs Fantasy Football Metrics	✓		41	28	50	41	38	198	39.6
43	Dan Hope Eleven Warriors	✓		33	30	49	47	38	197	39.4
44	Eddie Brown San Diego Union Tribune	✓	✓	45	35	44	39	34	197	39.4
45	David P. Woods theScore	✓	✓	39	36	39	44	38	196	39.2
46	Hayden Winks Underdog Fantasy	✓	✓	39	36	41	40	39	195	39.0
47	Ryan Noonan 4for4	✓	✓	38	35	33	43	46	195	39.0
48	Dan Bilicki Toronto Sun	✓		38	27	45	44	40	194	38.8
49	Kyle Crabbs The 33rd Team	✓	✓	38	33	42	43	38	194	38.8
50	Michael Levitsky The Future	✓		40	32	41	43	38	194	38.8
51	Rob Staton Seahawks Draft Blog	✓	✓	35	38	42	43	36	194	38.8
52	Justin Bales FFToday 📊 FantasyPros Tracked · View Profile →		✓	33*	33*	52*	40*	36*	194	38.8
53	Matt Miller ESPN 📺 FantasyPros Tracked · View Profile →		✓	42*	30*	40*	44*	38*	194	38.8
54	Andrew Lalama RotoBaller	✓	✓	43	34	50	36	30	193	38.6
55	Josh Norris Underdog 🏆 All-Time HR Record (59 pts) · View Profile →	✓	✓	38	36	38	43	38	193	38.6
56	Mike Luchene NFL Rough Draft	✓		44	33	37	38	41	193	38.6
57	Robby Esch The Huddle Report	✓		41	34	45	34	39	193	38.6
58	Shane P. Hallam Draft Sharks	✓	✓	42	38	39	36	38	193	38.6
59	Brett Clancy Drafttek	✓		38	35	37	45	37	192	38.4
60	Cody Carpentier RosterWatch	✓		31	39	40	39	43	192	38.4
61	Sean Green SGPN	✓	✓	31	45	42	38	36	192	38.4
62	Bill Dow NFL Draft Shark	✓		35	31	50	37	38	191	38.2
63	Trevor Sikkema PFF	✓	✓	35	39	42	43	32	191	38.2
64	Dylan Chappine Wolf Sports	✓		39	35	46	38	32	190	38.0
65	Hunter Ansley Drafticipation	✓		43	32	38	37	40	190	38.0
66	Enoch Autry The Clayton Tribune	✓		36	31	44	39	39	189	37.8
67	George Carmi The Big Doug & Carmi Show	✓		35	37	44	39	34	189	37.8
68	Jody Smith FullTime Fantasy	✓		40	32	40	37	40	189	37.8
69	Jonah Anderson Draft Dive	✓		35	31	48	39	36	189	37.8
70	Alex Dunlap RosterWatch	✓		37	39	40	35	37	188	37.6
71	Brentley Weissman PFSN	✓		40	31	40	38	38	187	37.4
72	Brian Bosarge Draft Countdown	✓		39	40	37	31	40	187	37.4
73	Doug Martz Draft Board Guru	✓		35	36	38	41	37	187	37.4
74	Jimmy Kempski Philly Voice	✓	✓	43	32	39	38	35	187	37.4
75	JP Miguel 10 Jardas	✓		37	32	42	38	38	187	37.4
76	Ray Mencio NFL Rough Draft	✓	✓	39	35	41	32	40	187	37.4
77	Michael Campbell The Draft Zone	✓		42	36	38	37	33	186	37.2
78	Anthony Macari Pro Football War Room	✓		39	27	43	40	36	185	37.0
79	JT Olson Bucs Report	✓		42	35	38	38	32	185	37.0
80	Sam Farmer Los Angeles Times	✓	✓	41	31	44	37	32	185	37.0
81	Jason Pruett DRAFTPLEX	✓	✓	36	36	45	37	30	184	36.8
82	Kent Weyrauch Fantasy Pros	✓	✓	38	39	36	39	32	184	36.8
83	James Fedewa National Fanatic	✓		35	31	38	40	39	183	36.6
84	Clevta Clevanalytics	✓		36	32	39	43	32	182	36.4
85	Tony Martone The Future	✓		33	37	42	41	28	181	36.2
86	David Payne DraftTek	✓		31	38	41	38	32	180	36.0
87	Theo Luzader Draft it Up Podcast	✓		43	32	40	34	31	180	36.0
88	Nathan Cooper Sports Info Solutions	✓		40	33	37	36	33	179	35.8
89	Josh Greene Fox Sports Spartanburg	✓		32	31	43	39	32	177	35.4
90	Anthony Amico In the Aggregate	✓	✓	36	32	35	37	36	176	35.2
91	Drew Boylhart The Huddle Report	✓		32	32	42	37	33	176	35.2
92	Alex Boylhart The Huddle Report	✓		37	28	45	32	31	173	34.6
93	Frank Coyle Draft Insiders	✓		31	32	39	35	36	173	34.6
94	Joe Marino Locked on NFL Scouting	✓	✓	33	31	36	36	37	173	34.6
95	Tyler Forness A TO Z Sports	✓		36	31	33	34	37	171	34.2
96	Mark Morales-Smith FantasySP	✓		32	28	41	34	35	170	34.0
97	Benjamin Robinson Grinding the Mocks	✓		30	34	38	33	32	167	33.4
98	Scott Carasik ScarDraft	✓		33	32	38	33	29	165	33.0

Most Accurate Mock Draft Analysts – Past 5 Years (2022–2026)

This leaderboard ranks 203+ professional mock draft analysts by their accuracy over the past five draft classes (2022–2026). A five-year window balances recency with sample size — analysts who have been consistently accurate across multiple drafts rise to the top, while a single breakout or breakdown year doesn't dominate the rankings.

The rankings use The Huddle Report scoring system (96 points max per year) by default, with FantasyPros scoring (320 points max) available as an alternative. Toggle between systems to see how different accuracy definitions reshape the rankings.

For career-spanning rankings, see the all-time leaderboard. For a shorter recency window, check the past 3 years leaderboard. Want to compete? Build your 2027 mock draft and see where you rank.

Loading…

Rank

Name

Total ▼

Avg/Yr

🥇

Jason Boris

Times News

👑 2024 HR Champion · View Profile →

✓

235

47.0

🥈

Charlie Campbell

WalterFootball

📊 2021 FP Champion · View Profile →

✓

227

45.4

🥉

Nick Guarisco

Fantasy Law Guy

⚖️ MDDB Top-6 2019–21 · View Profile →

221

44.2

Scott Smith

4for4

📊 View Profile →

✓

218

43.6

Brendan Donahue

Sharp Football Analysis

📊 View Profile →

✓

216

43.2

Matthew Freedman

Fantasy Life

📊 View Profile →

✓

216

43.2

Jared Smola

Draft Sharks

📊 View Profile →

✓

215

43.0

Forrest N. Long

The Huddle Report

✓

213

42.6

Ron Stewart

YouTube

✓

213

42.6

Lance Zierlein

NFL.com

📺 NFL.com Senior Analyst · View Profile →

◐

✓

50*

213

42.6

Walter Cherepinsky

WalterFootball

📊 2x Top-5 FantasyPros · View Profile →

✓

213

42.6

Benjamin Klotz

Touchdown Squad

✓

212

42.4

Daniel Jeremiah

NFL Network

📺 Former NFL Scout · View Profile →

✓

212

42.4

Ryan Towles

The Huddle Report

✓

212

42.4

Andrew Erickson

FantasyPros

✓

211

42.2

Kennedy Paynter

Drafttek

✓

211

42.2

Ryan McCrystal

Draft Ace

✓

211

42.2

Brian Johannes

The Huddle Report

✓

210

42.0

Peter Schrager

NFL Network

📺 3x Top-10 FantasyPros · View Profile →

✓

209

41.8

Ben Standig

The Athletic

✓

208

41.6

Mike Band

Next Gen Stats / RosterWatch

✓

208

41.6

Michael Middlehurst-Schwartz

USA Today

✓

207

41.4

Mel Kiper Jr.

ESPN

📺 Draft Expert Since 1984 · View Profile →

◐

✓

40*

34*

49*

206

41.2

Brian Phlipot

The Football Hub

✓

205

41.0

Eric Galko

Optimum Scouting

✓

205

41.0

Lou Pickney

Mock Draft NFL

📊 View Profile →

✓

205

41.0

Walt Deptula

The Roar FM

✓

205

41.0

Tom Downey

Chat Sports

✓

204

40.8

John Daigle

Establish The Run

✓

203

40.6

Mark Niemi

The Huddle Report

✓

203

40.6

Scott Atkins

FullTime Fantasy

✓

203

40.6

Xavier Cromartie

Fantasy Football Metrics

✓

203

40.6

Jeremy Bissett

The Bissett Perspective

✓

202

40.4

Peter Clarke

The Huddle Report

✓

201

40.2

Shawn Baptist

The Huddle Report

✓

201

40.2

Kevin Hanson

Eat Drink & Sleep Football

✓

200

40.0

Matthew Jones

FantasyPros

✓

200

40.0

Jonathan Cook

The Huddle Report

✓

199

39.8

Michael Delaney

The Huddle Report

✓

199

39.8

Russell Brown

FantasyPros / LionsWire

📊 View Profile →

✓

199

39.8

Nick Jacobs

KSHB-TV

✓

198

39.6

Ross Jacobs

Fantasy Football Metrics

✓

198

39.6

Dan Hope

Eleven Warriors

✓

197

39.4

Eddie Brown

San Diego Union Tribune

✓

197

39.4

David P. Woods

theScore

✓

196

39.2

Hayden Winks

Underdog Fantasy

✓

195

39.0

Ryan Noonan

4for4

✓

195

39.0

Dan Bilicki

Toronto Sun

✓

194

38.8

Kyle Crabbs

The 33rd Team

✓

194

38.8

Michael Levitsky

The Future

✓

194

38.8

Rob Staton

Seahawks Draft Blog

✓

194

38.8

Justin Bales

FFToday

📊 FantasyPros Tracked · View Profile →

✓

194

38.8

Matt Miller

ESPN

📺 FantasyPros Tracked · View Profile →

✓

194

38.8

Andrew Lalama

RotoBaller

✓

193

38.6

Josh Norris

Underdog

🏆 All-Time HR Record (59 pts) · View Profile →

✓

193

38.6

Mike Luchene

NFL Rough Draft

✓

193

38.6

Robby Esch

The Huddle Report

✓

193

38.6

Shane P. Hallam

Draft Sharks

✓

193

38.6

Brett Clancy

Drafttek

✓

192

38.4

Cody Carpentier

RosterWatch

✓

192

38.4

Sean Green

SGPN

✓

192

38.4

Bill Dow

NFL Draft Shark

✓

191

38.2

Trevor Sikkema

PFF

✓

191

38.2

Dylan Chappine

Wolf Sports

✓

190

38.0

Hunter Ansley

Drafticipation

✓

190

38.0

Enoch Autry

The Clayton Tribune

✓

189

37.8

George Carmi

The Big Doug & Carmi Show

✓

189

37.8

Jody Smith

FullTime Fantasy

✓

189

37.8

Jonah Anderson

Draft Dive

✓

189

37.8

Alex Dunlap

RosterWatch

✓

188

37.6

Brentley Weissman

PFSN

✓

187

37.4

Brian Bosarge

Draft Countdown

✓

187

37.4

Doug Martz

Draft Board Guru

✓

187

37.4

Jimmy Kempski

Philly Voice

✓

187

37.4

JP Miguel

10 Jardas

✓

187

37.4

Ray Mencio

NFL Rough Draft

✓

187

37.4

Michael Campbell

The Draft Zone

✓

186

37.2

Anthony Macari

Pro Football War Room

✓

185

37.0

JT Olson

Bucs Report

✓

185

37.0

Sam Farmer

Los Angeles Times

✓

185

37.0

Jason Pruett

DRAFTPLEX

✓

184

36.8

Kent Weyrauch

Fantasy Pros

✓

184

36.8

James Fedewa

National Fanatic

✓

183

36.6

Clevta

Clevanalytics

✓

182

36.4

Tony Martone

The Future

✓

181

36.2

David Payne

DraftTek

✓

180

36.0

Theo Luzader

Draft it Up Podcast

✓

180

36.0

Nathan Cooper

Sports Info Solutions

✓

179

35.8

Josh Greene

Fox Sports Spartanburg

✓

177

35.4

Anthony Amico

In the Aggregate

✓

176

35.2

Drew Boylhart

The Huddle Report

✓

176

35.2

Alex Boylhart

The Huddle Report

✓

173

34.6

Frank Coyle

Draft Insiders

✓

173

34.6

Joe Marino

Locked on NFL Scouting

✓

173

34.6

Tyler Forness

A TO Z Sports

✓

171

34.2

Mark Morales-Smith

FantasySP

✓

170

34.0

Benjamin Robinson

Grinding the Mocks

✓

167

33.4

Scott Carasik

ScarDraft

✓

165

33.0

Most Accurate Mock Draft Analysts – Past 5 Years (2022–2026)

For career-spanning rankings, see the all-time leaderboard. For a shorter recency window, check the past 3 years leaderboard. Want to compete? Build your 2027 mock draft and see where you rank.

🏆 Most Accurate NFL Mock Drafts – Past 5 Years

📊 See How You Compare to the Analysts

Most Accurate Mock Draft Analysts – Past 5 Years (2022–2026)

🏆 Most Accurate NFL Mock Drafts – Past 5 Years

📊 See How You Compare to the Analysts

Most Accurate Mock Draft Analysts – Past 5 Years (2022–2026)