Loading…
🌐 2023 Consensus Mock Draft vs Actual Results
What everyone thought would happen — and what actually did. Pick whose mocks make up the consensus: the 17 analysts MDS tracks pick-by-pick (a sample that skews toward widely-read, high-ranking analysts — not all 203+ scored analysts), the community's saved mocks, or any mix. Compare against MDDB's 100+-analyst consensus and see how accurate mock drafts really are.
Build your consensus — whose mocks count?
All Analysts (17)
Compare against
🏛️ MDDB Consensus
Scores out of 93 (Huddle Report) · per pick max 3
Consensus Score
38
would rank ~#29 of 132 analysts
Consensus R1 Right
26
of 29 unique players picked
Best call
#8 Robinson
65% agreement — nailed it
Biggest miss
#4 Levis
47% agreed — went #33
MDDB Consensus Score
34
would rank ~#74 of 132 analysts
MDDB Consensus R1 Right
24
of 31 picks
| Pick | Team | Consensus Pick | # Mocked | Consensus Pts | MDDB Pick ↗ | MDDB Pts | Actual Pick |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  CAR | Bryce YoungQB | 17 of 17 (100%) | ✓ 3 | Bryce YoungQB | ✓ 3 | CARBryce YoungQB |
| 2 |  HOU | Will Anderson Jr.EDGE | 13 of 17 (76%) | ◐ 3 | Will Anderson Jr.EDGE | ◐ 3 | HOUC.J. StroudQB |
| 3 |  ARI | Paris Johnson Jr.OT | 6 of 17 (35%) | ◐ 3 | Tyree WilsonEDGE | ◐ 1 | HOUWill Anderson Jr.EDGE |
| 4 |  IND | Will LevisQB | 8 of 17 (47%) | ✗ 0 | Will LevisQB | ✗ 0 | INDAnthony RichardsonQB |
| 5 |  SEA | Jalen CarterDT | 13 of 17 (76%) | ◐ 1 | Jalen CarterDT | ◐ 1 | SEADevon WitherspoonCB |
| 6 |  DET | Devon WitherspoonCB | 16 of 17 (94%) | ◐ 1 | Devon WitherspoonCB | ◐ 1 | ARIParis Johnson Jr.OT |
| 7 |  LV | Christian GonzalezCB | 10 of 17 (59%) | ◐ 1 | Christian GonzalezCB | ◐ 1 | LVTyree WilsonEDGE |
| 8 |  ATL | Bijan RobinsonRB | 11 of 17 (65%) | ✓ 3 | Bijan RobinsonRB | ✓ 3 | ATLBijan RobinsonRB |
| 9 |  CHI | 4 of 17 (24%) | ◐ 3 ◐ 1 ◐ 1 | Paris Johnson Jr.OT | ◐ 1 |  PHIJalen CarterDT | |
| 10 | PHI | Nolan SmithEDGE | 9 of 17 (53%) | ◐ 3 | Nolan SmithEDGE | ◐ 3 | CHIDarnell WrightOT |
| 11 |  TEN | Anthony RichardsonQB | 5 of 17 (29%) | ◐ 1 | Peter SkoronskiOT | ✓ 3 | TENPeter SkoronskiOT |
| 12 | HOU | Jaxon Smith-NjigbaWR | 4 of 17 (24%) | ◐ 1 | Jaxon Smith-NjigbaWR | ◐ 1 | DETJahmyr GibbsRB |
| 13 |  GB | Jaxon Smith-NjigbaWR | 7 of 17 (41%) | ◐ 1 | Dalton KincaidTE | ◐ 1 |  NYJWill McDonald IVEDGE |
| 14 |  NE | Peter SkoronskiOT | 5 of 17 (29%) | ◐ 1 | Broderick JonesOT | ◐ 1 | NEChristian GonzalezCB |
| 15 | NYJ | Broderick JonesOT | 7 of 17 (41%) | ◐ 1 | Darnell WrightOT | ◐ 1 | GBLukas Van NessEDGE |
| 16 |  WAS | Emmanuel ForbesCB | 6 of 17 (35%) | ✓ 3 | Joey Porter Jr.CB | ✗ 0 | WASEmmanuel ForbesCB |
| 17 |  PIT | Broderick JonesOT | 6 of 17 (35%) | ✓ 3 | Deonte BanksCB | ◐ 1 | PITBroderick JonesOT |
| 18 | DET | Lukas Van NessEDGE | 5 of 17 (29%) | ◐ 1 | Calijah KanceyDT | ◐ 1 | DETJack CampbellLB |
| 19 |  TB | Anton HarrisonOT | 8 of 17 (47%) | ◐ 1 | Anton HarrisonOT | ◐ 1 | TBCalijah KanceyDT |
| 20 | SEA | 4 of 17 (24%) | ◐ 1 ◐ 1 | Myles MurphyEDGE | ◐ 1 | SEAJaxon Smith-NjigbaWR | |
| 21 |  LAC | Michael MayerTE | 4 of 17 (24%) | ✗ 0 | Jordan AddisonWR | ◐ 1 | LACQuentin JohnstonWR |
| 22 |  BAL | Deonte BanksCB | 6 of 17 (35%) | ◐ 1 | Emmanuel ForbesCB | ◐ 1 | BALZay FlowersWR |
| 23 |  MIN | Jordan AddisonWR | 5 of 17 (29%) | ✓ 3 | Hendon HookerQB | ✗ 0 | MINJordan AddisonWR |
| 24 |  JAX | Deonte BanksCB | 4 of 17 (24%) | ◐ 1 | Brian BranchS | ✗ 0 | JAXAnton HarrisonOT |
| 25 |  NYG | Jordan AddisonWR | 4 of 17 (24%) | ◐ 1 | Quentin JohnstonWR | ◐ 1 | NYGDeonte BanksCB |
| 26 |  DAL | Michael MayerTE | 8 of 17 (47%) | ✗ 0 | Michael MayerTE | ✗ 0 | DALMazi SmithDT |
| 27 |  BUF | 2 of 17 (12%) | ◐ 1 ◐ 1 ◐ 1 ✗ 0 ◐ 1 | O'Cyrus TorrenceG | ✗ 0 | BUFDalton KincaidTE | |
| 28 |  CIN | 2 of 17 (12%) | ◐ 1 ◐ 1 ◐ 1 ✗ 0 | Jahmyr GibbsRB | ◐ 1 | CINMyles MurphyEDGE | |
| 29 |  NO | 4 of 17 (24%) | ◐ 1 ◐ 1 | Will McDonald IVEDGE | ◐ 1 | NOBryan BreseeDT | |
| 30 | PHI | Jahmyr GibbsRB | 5 of 17 (29%) | ◐ 1 | Bryan BreseeDT | ◐ 1 | PHINolan SmithEDGE |
| 31 |  KC | Quentin JohnstonWR | 5 of 17 (29%) | ◐ 1 | Jalin HyattWR | ✗ 0 | KCFelix Anudike-UzomahEDGE |
✓ exact call · ◐ right player, wrong slot (still Round 1) · ✗ fell out of Round 1. Points use the Huddle Report method (1 pt right player in R1, +2 team match) — switch methods with the scoring selector in the navbar. Split slots (5) show every tied pick, and the slot scores the average of them — a 2-way split where the picks earn 3 and 1 counts as 2, so a tie never earns double credit. Because each slot's consensus is computed independently, the same player can appear at multiple slots — something no real mock draft allows — so only a player's best-scoring slot counts toward the totals (the per-row points still show what each slot would have earned).
How the Consensus Mock Draft Works
The consensus takes the final first-round mock from every selected source — tracked analysts, community members, or your own custom mix — and finds the most-predicted player at each slot. When sources tie, the slot shows a split with every tied pick. Each consensus pick is graded against the actual draft with the same scoring systems used on the accuracy leaderboard — so you can see whether the hive mind beats the individual experts.
Compare your consensus against the MDDB professional consensus mock, dig into accuracy by pick range, then build your own mock draft and decide where to follow the crowd and where to break from consensus.